Thinking about stepping into the under-65 insurance market but unsure if it’s worth your time? You’re not alone—and the good news is, the Affordable Care Act (ACA) offers strong commission opportunities that can make it well worth the effort.
The ACA marketplace holds significant income potential for agents. While commission levels vary depending on factors like carrier, state, and plan type, this flexibility allows you to shape your own ACA business strategy. Whether you’re running a small agency or building a larger book of business, ACA plans can create a profitable and sustainable revenue stream.
Commission Payments
If you’ve worked in insurance before, you’re likely familiar with the hierarchy structures that exist within field marketing organizations (FMOs). At Essential Care, hierarchies are organized into levels one through nine, based on the number of agents above and below each agent. This structure can influence how commissions flow—something most common in Medicare sales but still relevant when selling ACA marketplace plans.
ACA commissions are paid monthly, with most carriers issuing payments early in the month. Keep in mind, commissions are only released once the member’s premium has been paid and successfully posted to their account for the prior month.
When to Expect Commission Payments
If you’re coming from other lines of insurance, you may notice the commission timeline for under-65 products looks a little different. Most carriers issue the first monthly commission one to two months after the policy’s effective date. However, a few factors can impact when you actually receive payment.
-
Late Premiums: If a client delays their binder or premium payment, your commission will also be delayed.
-
Unauthorized Plan Switches: If your client is switched into another plan or has their agent of record changed without authorization, you could lose commissions altogether. Always verify that your clients appear in your business book within your marketplace enrollment account.
If you are properly listed as the agent of record but haven’t received payment within the expected timeframe, reach out to your FMO—or directly to the carrier if you’re paid that way. Essential Care agents can find carrier contact information in the Agent Hub.
Finally, keep in mind that CMS is actively working to combat marketplace fraud and implement safeguards to protect agents. In fact, unexpected changes in your commission payments may be one of the earliest warning signs that fraudulent activity has occurred.
What Factors Influence Under-65 Commissions?
Unlike Medicare, the ACA doesn’t set fixed guidelines for agent commissions. As a result, earnings can vary based on factors such as the state you sell in, the type of plan selected, and the number of household members enrolled. Understanding these variables can help you maximize the income potential of the under-65 market.
State Exchanges
Commission rates differ from state to state, with each exchange setting its own rules for what agents can earn. For example, one Florida carrier pays $30 per member, per month (PMPM)—a structure that can quickly add up when insuring families.
Since 2017, commissions in the ACA market have generally risen and remain competitive as the industry adapts to changing needs.
Per Member vs. Per Contract
The most common structure is per member, per month (PMPM). This means you receive a commission for every covered household member each month. Enrolling multiple family members magnifies your earnings.
Some carriers, however, pay per contract, per month (PCPM)—a flat monthly rate regardless of the number of individuals covered under that plan.
Agents earn initial commissions in the first year of enrollment, followed by renewal commissions in subsequent years. While many carriers pay the same rate for renewals, some do reduce the payout after year one.
Plan Type
The type of plan sold also affects commission amounts. Health Maintenance Organization (HMO), Preferred Provider Organization (PPO), and Exclusive Provider Organization (EPO) plans can each carry different commission rates. In some cases, carriers offer higher payouts for HMO or EPO plans.
How Much Can Agents Earn Selling ACA Plans?
To put the earning potential into perspective, here’s an example:
Jim, an independent agent in Illinois, earns about $20 per member, per month (PMPM) for each ACA policy he sells. When he enrolls a 43-year-old mother and her two children, that family generates $60 per month in commissions. Over the course of a year, that’s $720 from just one household.
And it doesn’t stop there. As long as clients stay enrolled, agents continue to earn commissions each month. On top of that, many carriers offer production-based bonuses during the Open Enrollment Period (OEP), which can significantly boost total earnings.
By partnering with an FMO like Essential Care, you can maximize these opportunities even further. We provide hands-on training, sales support, streamlined contracting assistance, and advanced technology tools designed to save you time and help you grow your book of business. The result? More clients, more closed sales, and greater commission potential.
OEP vs. SEP Commissions in the ACA Market
In the past, some carriers paid different commission rates for enrollments made during the Open Enrollment Period (OEP) compared to those made during Special Enrollment Periods (SEPs). That practice has since changed.
Starting in 2022, CMS required that commissions be the same for both OEP and SEP sales. The reasoning was simple: paying less for SEP enrollments discouraged agents from assisting clients outside of OEP, which CMS determined to be a discriminatory practice.
Today, most carriers offer equal compensation for new enrollments and renewals alike—creating consistent earning opportunities for agents year-round.
Partner with Essential Care’s Under-65 Sales Team
At Essential Care, our dedicated Under-65 Sales team is here to guide and support you every step of the way as you grow your ACA business. By registering on our site, you’ll gain free access to a full suite of tools, resources, and training designed to help you succeed.
Connect with our Sales team today and start unlocking more opportunities—and more earnings—through selling ACA insurance.
Not affiliated with or endorsed by Medicare or any government agency.
GET CONTRACTED WITH ESSENTIAL CARE INSURANCE AGENCY
For more information, please contact our office at (347) 971-3399 or send an email to rdashevskyy@essentialcare.info. Essential Care Insurance Agency provides Free Programs and Sales Tools for our Agents:
Please click on each link to learn more