It’s no secret that some carriers are now designating certain Medicare Advantage (MA) and Part D plans as non-commissionable — a change that can impact your business and income.
If you find yourself in this situation, don’t worry — Essential Care is here to help you navigate the transition and explore your best next steps!
Carriers with Non-Commissionable Plans in 2026
Several major carriers — including UnitedHealthcare, Elevance Health (formerly Anthem), Aetna, HealthSpring (formerly Cigna Healthcare), and WellCare — have announced commission changes for their 2026 Medicare Advantage (MA) plan portfolios.
Some of these carriers will no longer pay commissions on select MA plans in certain markets.
As always, Essential Care is staying ahead of the curve. We’re closely monitoring these updates and providing our agents with the latest details, insights, and strategies to help you adapt and keep your business running strong.
Why Are Some Medicare Plans Becoming Non-Commissionable?
Many carriers are reducing or removing agent commissions on certain Medicare Advantage (MA) plans — particularly PPO options — as a cost-control measure. These adjustments are often driven by lower plan profitability and rising administrative expenses.
Although the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) recently raised the maximum allowable broker compensation, carriers are not required to pay the full amount. As a result, some have chosen to scale back commissions selectively across markets.
Adding to the uncertainty, a federal court decision in August 2025 vacated part of a CMS rule that would have limited how carriers compensate Third-Party Marketing Organizations (TPMOs). This ruling has left commission standards in flux, and some carriers may see it as an opportunity to reassess or further reduce payouts.
As one carrier stated:
“To best optimize the experience for our members and partners, we’ve made the decision to make specific plans non-commissionable starting September 1, 2025.”
Why Make This Change During AEP?
The Annual Enrollment Period (AEP) is the busiest time of year for MA sales, when millions of beneficiaries review and switch plans. By implementing these changes ahead of AEP, carriers aim to adjust spending and stabilize costs before enrollment peaks.
This move may also be a response to increased plan utilization. During the COVID-19 pandemic, many beneficiaries delayed medical care, leading to temporarily reduced claim costs. Now that healthcare usage has returned to normal levels, insurers are seeing higher benefit utilization, prompting tighter budget measures — including making certain plans non-commissionable.
The Bottom Line
While these shifts may feel discouraging, they’re part of the ever-changing Medicare landscape. The most successful agents adapt quickly, pivot strategically, and continue to thrive through change.
With the right support and planning, you can still make this AEP your strongest yet — and Essential Care is here to help you every step of the way.
What to Do If Your Medicare Plans Become Non-Commissionable
When a carrier decides to make certain Medicare Advantage (MA) or Part D plans non-commissionable, it can feel frustrating — especially if it impacts your income. But remember: your role as an agent is much bigger than just earning commissions.
You can (and should) continue to quote and offer these plans when they’re the best fit for your clients. If the plan isn’t available for agent enrollment, you can still help clients enroll directly through Medicare.gov.
While you won’t earn a commission from those sales, what you will earn — trust, loyalty, and long-term relationships — are the true foundations of success in this business.
By creating customized coverage packages that include products like hospital indemnity, dental-vision-hearing (DVH), critical illness, final expense, or life insurance, you can better protect your clients and strengthen your income stream.
Clients who feel well-taken-care-of often become repeat customers and referral sources, leading to even more growth — all from one commission-free sale.
So, what should you do next? Here are seven specific actions to help you adapt and thrive when plans go non-commissionable.
1. Take a Breather and Re-Center Yourself
It’s natural to feel discouraged when a major part of your earnings suddenly changes. Many agents spend years building their renewal base, so any disruption can feel overwhelming.
Before making big decisions, take a step back. Give yourself a day or two to regroup, reflect, and reconnect with your “why.”
Why did you become an agent? Was it the freedom of schedule, your passion for helping seniors, or the ability to provide for your family? Reminding yourself of that purpose helps you reset your mindset and move forward with clarity and focus.
Once you’ve realigned with your purpose, ask yourself — “What now?” — and start planning your next steps.
2. Keep Your Clients’ Best Interests First
At Essential Care, we believe that when you put the client first, everything else falls into place — your reputation, your referrals, and ultimately your income.
If a non-commissionable plan is still the right fit for your client, recommend it confidently. You probably chose to represent that plan because it met real needs — and those reasons still hold true.
Doing what’s best for your client, even when there’s no financial incentive, builds trust and long-term loyalty that will benefit your business far beyond a single commission check.
3. Expand Your Portfolio with Commissionable Plans
This may be a perfect time to diversify your portfolio by contracting with additional carriers and exploring new commissionable MA or PDP options.
Consider adding Medicare Advantage Prescription Drug (MAPD) plans — they’ve continued to grow in popularity since 2007 thanks to their comprehensive coverage and added benefits.
MAPD plans also offer competitive commission structures for both new sales and renewals. Since CMS updates the annual maximum commission limits, many carriers stay competitive by paying the full allowable amount.
4. Strengthen Your Cross-Selling Strategy
Cross-selling is one of the most effective ways to protect your clients while supplementing your income. Offer relevant ancillary products such as:
-
Hospital indemnity
-
Critical illness
-
Final expense
-
Dental-Vision-Hearing (DVH)
-
Life insurance
Always remain compliant — ensure the Scope of Appointment (SOA) includes ancillary products before discussing them in a Medicare appointment.
If ancillary products aren’t marked on the SOA, wait and schedule a follow-up appointment to present them properly. Never push additional products just to make a sale — only recommend what truly benefits your client’s needs.
5. Revisit Medicare Supplement Opportunities
If you currently sell Prescription Drug Plans (PDPs), consider expanding into Medicare Supplement (Med Supp) plans as well. The two often complement each other perfectly.
Review your current Med Supp contracts and explore new or more competitive options available in your market.
Remember — if a client’s MA plan is terminated, they may qualify for guaranteed issue rights to switch to a Med Supp plan. However, not all carriers pay full commissions on guaranteed issue business, so check each carrier’s rules carefully.
Plan N remains one of the most balanced options, offering affordable premiums and strong coverage. You can also pair Med Supp or high-deductible plans with hospital indemnity coverage to provide clients with more personalized protection.
6. Ask for Referrals
Referrals are the lifeblood of a sustainable business, especially during times of transition. Don’t assume happy clients will spread the word — ask them directly.
Try a simple approach like handing them a few business cards and saying,
“If you know anyone who could use some help with their Medicare coverage, feel free to pass along my contact info.”
Satisfied clients who trust you are often eager to refer family and friends, helping you grow your book organically without added marketing costs.
7. Partner with an FMO Like Essential Care
When the industry shifts, strong partnerships make all the difference. That’s where Essential Care comes in.
Our team is here to help you navigate change with confidence — offering access to competitive contracts, valuable training, and powerful tools like Sunfire and Connecture DRX, which streamline quoting and enrollment while keeping you compliant.
Working with an FMO ensures you never have to face changes alone — you’ll always have support, insight, and technology working in your favor.
Final Thoughts
Having plans go non-commissionable can feel like a setback, but it doesn’t have to be. With the right mindset and strategy, it can actually become an opportunity to refocus, diversify, and strengthen your business.
Change is part of the Medicare industry — but so is resilience. With Essential Care’s support, you can turn this challenge into momentum and make the upcoming AEP one of your strongest seasons yet.
Not affiliated with or endorsed by Medicare or any government agency.
GET CONTRACTED WITH ESSENTIAL CARE INSURANCE AGENCY
For more information, please contact our office at (347) 971-3399 or send an email to rdashevskyy@essentialcare.info. Essential Care Insurance Agency provides Free Programs and Sales Tools for our Agents:
Please click on each link to learn more